A broken collarbone, medically known as a clavicle fracture, is one of the most common bone injuries, particularly among children and young adults. The collarbone is the long, slender bone that connects your breastbone to your shoulder blade, and it plays a crucial role in connecting your arm to your body. This injury typically occurs from a fall onto an outstretched arm, a direct blow to the shoulder, or during contact sports and vehicle accidents.
Recognizing the signs of a broken collarbone is essential for seeking prompt medical attention and preventing complications. While some symptoms are immediately obvious, others may develop gradually. Understanding these warning signs can help you determine when to visit a healthcare provider and ensure proper healing of this important bone structure.
1. Immediate Sharp Pain in the Shoulder or Collarbone Area
The most prominent and immediate symptom of a broken collarbone is sudden, intense pain located at the site of the fracture. This pain typically occurs at the moment of injury and is often described as sharp, stabbing, or severe.
The pain is usually localized to the collarbone region but may radiate to the shoulder, neck, or upper arm. What makes this pain particularly distinctive is its intensity—it’s often severe enough to make any movement of the arm or shoulder extremely uncomfortable or nearly impossible. The pain may worsen with any attempt to lift the arm, move the shoulder, or even take deep breaths, as breathing causes slight movement of the rib cage and collarbone.
Many patients report that the pain is so significant that they instinctively hold their arm close to their body in an attempt to minimize movement and discomfort. This natural protective response is the body’s way of immobilizing the injured area.
2. Visible Deformity or Bump on the Shoulder
A broken collarbone often creates a visible physical change in the shoulder area that can be quite alarming. You may notice a bump, bulge, or obvious deformity along the collarbone or at the top of the shoulder.
This deformity occurs because the broken bone ends may shift out of their normal alignment. In some cases, the shoulder may appear to sag or droop forward and downward on the affected side, as the collarbone can no longer provide its normal structural support. The bump you see or feel is typically the displaced bone fragments pushing against the skin.
In severe cases, particularly with displaced fractures, you might even see a tenting of the skin where the bone is pushing outward. However, it’s important to note that not all collarbone fractures produce visible deformities—some fractures, particularly hairline or non-displaced fractures, may not show obvious external changes but still cause significant pain and dysfunction.
3. Inability to Lift or Move the Arm
Loss of normal arm function is a hallmark sign of a broken collarbone. Most people with this injury find it extremely difficult or impossible to raise their arm on the affected side, especially above shoulder height.
This limitation occurs for several reasons. First, the severe pain associated with the fracture makes any movement intolerable. Second, the collarbone plays a crucial mechanical role in shoulder movement—it acts as a strut that holds the shoulder blade in position, allowing the arm to move freely. When the collarbone is broken, this structural support is compromised, disrupting the normal mechanics of shoulder and arm movement.
Patients typically report that even simple tasks become challenging or impossible, such as:
- Reaching overhead to grab objects
- Lifting the arm away from the body
- Getting dressed or undressed
- Carrying objects with the affected arm
- Performing daily hygiene activities
Most people instinctively support the injured arm with their other hand to minimize movement and reduce pain.
4. Swelling and Bruising Around the Collarbone
Swelling typically develops rapidly after a collarbone fracture, usually within the first few hours following the injury. The area around the fracture site becomes puffy and tender to the touch as the body’s inflammatory response kicks in.
Bruising, or ecchymosis, often appears within 24 to 48 hours after the injury. The bruising may start as redness and progress to purple, blue, green, and yellow as the body breaks down and reabsorbs the blood that has leaked from damaged blood vessels. The bruising may be quite extensive, spreading across the shoulder, upper chest, and even down the upper arm.
The amount of swelling and bruising can vary depending on the severity of the fracture. More severe breaks, particularly those involving multiple bone fragments or significant displacement, tend to produce more pronounced swelling and bruising. The swollen area may feel warm to the touch and appear shiny as the skin stretches over the accumulated fluid.
5. Grinding or Crackling Sensation (Crepitus)
Crepitus is a distinctive grinding, grating, or crackling sensation or sound that occurs when the broken bone ends rub against each other. This unsettling symptom is quite specific to bone fractures and can be both felt and sometimes heard.
You might experience crepitus when:
- Attempting to move your shoulder or arm
- Taking deep breaths
- When a healthcare provider examines the injury
- During any movement that causes slight shifting of the bone fragments
While crepitus is a reliable indicator of a fracture, it’s important not to deliberately try to reproduce this sensation, as doing so could worsen the injury by causing further displacement of the bone fragments or damaging surrounding soft tissues, nerves, or blood vessels. If you notice crepitus, it’s best to keep the area as still as possible and seek immediate medical attention.
6. Shoulder Stiffness and Drooping
A broken collarbone often causes the affected shoulder to appear drooped, sagging, or positioned lower than the uninjured shoulder. This drooping occurs because the collarbone normally acts as a supporting strut that holds the shoulder blade and shoulder in their proper position.
When this support is broken, gravity causes the shoulder to fall forward and downward. The shoulder blade may also rotate inward, causing the entire shoulder girdle to collapse. This creates an asymmetrical appearance when comparing both shoulders.
Along with the drooping, significant stiffness develops in the shoulder joint. This stiffness results from a combination of factors:
- Pain that inhibits normal movement
- Protective muscle spasm around the injury
- Swelling that limits range of motion
- The person’s natural tendency to immobilize the area
The stiffness makes it difficult to perform normal shoulder movements, and many people adopt a protective posture, holding the arm close to the body with the elbow bent.
7. Tenderness When Touching the Collarbone Area
Point tenderness—extreme sensitivity to touch at a specific location—is a highly reliable sign of a broken collarbone. When you gently press along the collarbone, there will be a particular spot that is significantly more painful than the surrounding areas.
This pinpoint tenderness corresponds directly to the fracture site. Even light pressure or gentle palpation over the broken area can cause sharp, intense pain that may make you flinch or pull away. Healthcare providers use this symptom during physical examination to help locate the exact position of the fracture.
The tenderness may be accompanied by:
- Increased warmth at the fracture site
- A feeling of instability or movement under the skin
- Sharp pain that radiates to nearby areas when touched
- Heightened sensitivity that persists for several days or weeks
It’s important to avoid repeatedly pressing on the tender area, as this can increase pain and potentially worsen the injury.
Common Causes of Broken Collarbone
Understanding what causes collarbone fractures can help you recognize risk situations and take appropriate precautions. The most common causes include:
Falls
Falling onto your shoulder or onto an outstretched arm is the leading cause of collarbone fractures. This commonly occurs during sporting activities, playground accidents in children, or simple trips and falls in daily life. The impact force transmits through the arm or directly to the shoulder, causing the collarbone to break.
Sports Injuries
Contact sports and high-impact activities pose significant risk for collarbone fractures. Sports with high rates of these injuries include:
- Football and rugby
- Hockey
- Wrestling
- Mountain biking and cycling
- Skiing and snowboarding
- Skateboarding
- Horseback riding
Motor Vehicle Accidents
Car, motorcycle, and bicycle accidents frequently result in collarbone fractures due to the high-energy impact involved. The collarbone may break from direct impact with the dashboard, steering wheel, or ground, or from the force transmitted through the shoulder during collision.
Birth Injuries
Newborns can sustain collarbone fractures during difficult deliveries, particularly during passage through the birth canal. This is one of the most common birth injuries but typically heals quickly without complications.
Direct Blows
A direct hit to the collarbone from a blunt object, another person, or during physical altercations can cause fractures. This may occur during contact sports or traumatic incidents.
Prevention Strategies
While not all collarbone fractures can be prevented, you can take several steps to reduce your risk:
Use Protective Equipment
When participating in high-risk sports or activities, always wear appropriate protective gear including shoulder pads, properly fitted helmets, and other sport-specific equipment. This equipment can absorb some of the impact force and reduce injury severity.
Practice Safe Techniques
Learn and practice proper falling techniques in sports like martial arts, which teach you how to roll or fall in ways that distribute impact force more evenly across your body rather than concentrating it on one area like the collarbone.
Maintain Bone Health
Keep your bones strong through:
- Adequate calcium and vitamin D intake
- Regular weight-bearing exercise
- Avoiding smoking and excessive alcohol consumption
- Managing conditions that affect bone density, such as osteoporosis
Create Safe Environments
Reduce fall risks at home and work by:
- Keeping floors clear of clutter and tripping hazards
- Using adequate lighting in all areas
- Installing handrails on stairs
- Using non-slip mats in bathrooms
- Wearing appropriate footwear with good traction
Drive Safely
Always wear your seatbelt properly positioned across your chest and lap to reduce injury severity in vehicle accidents. Ensure proper vehicle maintenance and follow traffic safety rules.
Frequently Asked Questions
How long does it take for a broken collarbone to heal?
Most collarbone fractures heal within 6 to 12 weeks for adults and 3 to 6 weeks for children. However, complete healing and return to full strength may take several months. Healing time depends on the severity of the fracture, the patient’s age, overall health, and adherence to treatment recommendations.
Can you move your arm if your collarbone is broken?
While you may be able to move your arm slightly, most people with broken collarbones experience severe pain and significant limitation in arm movement. The pain and mechanical disruption typically make it extremely difficult or impossible to raise the arm or move the shoulder normally. Any movement should be minimized until medical evaluation.
Should I go to the emergency room for a suspected broken collarbone?
Yes, you should seek immediate medical attention if you suspect a broken collarbone. Visit the emergency room or call for emergency services if you experience severe pain, visible deformity, inability to move your arm, or if the injury resulted from high-impact trauma. Prompt medical evaluation ensures proper diagnosis and treatment.
Will a broken collarbone heal on its own?
Many collarbone fractures can heal with conservative treatment involving immobilization with a sling or brace, without requiring surgery. However, medical supervision is essential to ensure proper alignment and healing. Some fractures, particularly those that are severely displaced or involve multiple fragments, may require surgical intervention. Never attempt to self-treat a suspected fracture.
What happens if a broken collarbone goes untreated?
Untreated collarbone fractures can lead to serious complications including improper healing (malunion), non-healing (nonunion), chronic pain, decreased shoulder function, nerve or blood vessel damage, and permanent deformity. These complications can significantly impact shoulder mobility and quality of life. Medical treatment is essential for optimal recovery.
Is a broken collarbone the same as a separated shoulder?
No, these are different injuries. A broken collarbone is a fracture of the clavicle bone itself. A separated shoulder, also called an AC separation, is an injury to the ligaments connecting the collarbone to the shoulder blade at the acromioclavicular (AC) joint. While both injuries affect the same area and may have similar symptoms, they require different treatments.
Can you break your collarbone without knowing it?
While most collarbone fractures cause immediate, severe pain that makes them difficult to ignore, minor hairline fractures or stress fractures might initially cause less dramatic symptoms. However, even these fractures typically cause noticeable pain, tenderness, and some limitation in movement. If you experience persistent shoulder or collarbone pain after an injury, even if symptoms seem mild, seek medical evaluation.
What should I do immediately after breaking my collarbone?
Immediately after injury, keep the arm as still as possible, apply ice wrapped in cloth to reduce swelling (never directly on skin), support the arm in a comfortable position close to your body, avoid eating or drinking in case surgery is needed, and seek emergency medical care. Do not attempt to realign the bone yourself or apply pressure to any protruding areas.
References:
- Mayo Clinic – Broken Collarbone
- American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons – Clavicle Fracture
- Johns Hopkins Medicine – Clavicle Fracture
- NHS – Broken Collarbone
- Cleveland Clinic – Broken Collarbone
The information on this page is for educational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Always consult a qualified healthcare provider before making decisions related to your health.
Read the full Disclaimer here →